Reviews   ::        

Articles   ::        

Home   ::        

Links   ::        

Archives   ::        

Search   ::        

About Us   ::        
 
HDTV Costs     

HDTV Guide     

Diskeeper 9     

Stor n Go PRO     

Blade SSD Server     

 
     
 
 

 
  PowerLeap PL-iP3/T 1.4GHz CPU Upgrade Review
 
 

Benchmarks

Test Bed:

Abit BE6-II (v1.1)
256MB Crucial PC133 (CAS 3)
32MB GeForce2 GTS
15GB Maxtor ATA/66 (5400RPM)

The first set of benchmarks were run with SiSoftware's Sandra 2002, which uses synthetic tests to determine performance. Though not a "real world" application, Sandra is still a very useful tool because it can isolate individual subsystems - in this case the CPU and memory.

The theoretical performance increase of the PowerLeap adapter over the P3-600 is 1400/600=233%.

SiSoft Sandra 2002
Test P-3 600E Celeron 1.4GHz % Change
MHz 600E 1400 233%
CPU Arith (Dhrystone ALU) 1618 3866 239%
CPU Arith (Whetstone FPU) 810 1883 232%
CPU Multi-Media (Integer) 3269 7658 234%
CPU Multi-Media (Floating-Point) 4000 9506 238%
Memory (RAM Int) 643 713 11%
Memory (RAM Float) 429 719 68%

From the results above, it is clear that the CPU is performing as advertised. All the CPU test results show that the 1.4GHz PowerLeap upgrade is approximately 233% faster than the P3-600. However, the memory tests didn't fare so well. For example, the Integer memory tests only showed a 11% improvement.

Mad Onion
Test P-3 600E Celeron 1.4GHz % Change
MHz 600E 1400 233%
3d Mark 2001 SE 2440 3527 45%
PC Mark 2002 CPU 1637 3414 209%
PC Mark 2002 Mem 1137 1441 127%
PC Mark 2002 HD 316 316 0%

The results above further confirm the SiSoft analysis - the CPU itself scales nicely, but the gains don't necessarily carry over to the other subsystems. The 3D Mark score only showed a 45% increase and there was no difference in hard drive performance.

Analysis

The SiSoft and Mad Onion results highlight a caveat with this kind of upgrade - a PC is only as good as its weakest link. Placing a supercharged engine in an aging PC may not give you the intended results. With the exception of the configuration difficulties, the CPU ran as expected. However, the CPU is just one component of the system. A CPU upgrade won't improve the Hard Drive performance. Also, memory performance does not scale with the increase in CPU speed.

Conclusion

So who might buy this kind of upgrade? Given the current pricing of RAM, if you have a lot of RAM with a fairly new motherboard and hard drive, then a CPU upgrade like the PowerLeap adapter may be an relatively inexpensive way ($170 from PowerLeap) to extend the live of your system. With Hyper-Threading CPU's from Intel and Hammer CPU's from AMD on the way, getting another 6-8 months out of your current PC may be all you need. However, if you have an older system with aging components, it is probably better to save your money until you have enough for a new machine (or a barebones system if you want to do things yourself!).

The ironic thing with this upgrade is that it might not be for the casual PC hobbyist because of the configuration issues. However, those who know the most about PC's probably wouldn't bother with this upgrade path.

PROS
Fast
Large Heatsink/Fan
CONS
Can be quite difficult to configure
Large Heatsink/Fan
Won't necessarily improve performance of older components

Previous Page    
Table of Contents
Page 1: Overview and Installation
Page 2: Benchmarks, Analysis and Conclusion

 
      Posted by: , November 14, 2002, 6:00 pm  

 
    Cool banner #1
 
 
       ::  USB News

       ::  Bjorn 3D

       ::  [H]ardOCP

       ::  BurnOutPC

       ::  I am Not a Geek

 
 
Top Products


Processors

AMD

Intel

More...


Cases

Antec

Enlight

More...


Motherboards

Abit

Asus

Tyan

More...


Sound Cards

Creative Labs

Hercules

More...


Graphic Cards

ATI

nVidia

More...


Hard Drives

IBM

Maxtor

Quantum

More...


 

 

 
2001 - 2004 Digital Silence
Digital Silence is not responsible for the information or the accuracy of the information above.
All trademarks and copyrights owned by their respective companies.

Graphical Design by Mohsin Ali
Website Layout by Universal Interactive

PHP Programming by Network Innovations
Additional HTML Programming by Moddin.Net